Consider the following description of a formalist approach to literary criticism: It allows us to evaluate competing interpretations of Lord of the Flies—whether the collapse of society is due to excessive suppression of humanity's "bestial" nature or insufficient restraint. By examining the text, we ask: Is there evidence of suppression or indulgence of this primal side? Does Ralph control Jack’s urges during the hunt? Would stricter rules have averted the breakdown? Did such order succeed in the novel’s adult world? What role does literary criticism serve in this context?
Explanation
Literary criticism, particularly from a formalist perspective, helps us compare conflicting readings by closely analyzing textual evidence. This approach guides us in deciding which interpretation aligns better with the text, thereby clarifying ambiguities and shaping informed judgments about literature.